Singapore

Asia market update; June

The Asia export trades are now as challenging as it was during the pandemic, with extremely tight vessel space, equipment shortages and port congestion colliding leading to a surge in spot rates, with analysts speculating it could reach USD 20,000/FEU on the Asia-Europe trade before too long.

Vessel schedule reliability is slipping, dropping below 50% on Asia-Europe and Asia-US East Coast trades in April, with further deterioration expected across all trade lanes.

Compared to a year ago, spot rates on the major Asia export trades are up significantly. For example, Asia-Europe +300%, Asia-US West Coast +200%, Asia-Mediterranean +200% and Asia-US East Coast up almost 150%.

The level of weekly increases is not slowing with week on week increases of between 10-20% now a sustained pattern with no sign of slowing.

There are several factors driving the rate increases, but the speed of change has created nervousness in the market, generating more demand and ‘highest bidder’ pricing.

Typically, retailers start importing goods for the November Black Friday sales and Christmas shopping season between late summer and autumn, but having experienced the pandemic’s capacity crisis, they are front-loading orders, fearing that there may be a capacity squeeze during the Q3 peak season.

This report by the BBC – ‘Shops rush for Christmas stock as shipping costs surge’ – confirms that retailers are placing orders early, as soaring costs and disruption threaten their supply chain deliveries.

One business told the BBC that increased costs were likely to feed through to the price on the high street and they were having to plan and book well in advance to make sure their Black Friday and Christmas stock arrive on time.

And even though it impacts cashflow and creates warehouse capacity challenges as they must store the goods for longer, they can’t risk ordering later, and potentially paying even higher freight rates or risk not being able to get cargo on a vessel at all.

There have been many articles in the trade press recently, reporting that container shipping lines are restricting allocations to beneficial cargo owners and freight forwarders alike, as carriers try to allocate space and equipment in a market where demand is far exceeding forecasted volumes.

We note that such reports refer to ‘sources’ rather than cite examples and whilst we are not immune to this, our carrier partners continue to be supportive and the strategic agreements we agreed are still intact, underpinned by strong relationships and decades of partnership.

In the current market we believe communication is paramount and we ask our customers to support us by providing advanced forecasts and early booking. This enables our team to plan and allocate capacity in an optimal way and reduces the risk of not being able to ship as planned.

To learn how we can enhance your ocean freight solutions, please EMAIL our Chief Commercial Officer, Andy Smith.

HKG port

Port congestion cannot be ignored

Significant and sustained terminal congestion in major Mediterranean and Asian ports is soaking up available capacity, which directly impacts freight rates and results in substantial delays to vessel schedules, with reliability dropping and the likelihood that delays will persist through the summer.

Port congestion has been building for months, adding more complexity to an already over-stretched container shipping market that is struggling to cope with shortages of vessel space and container equipment at key origins, as a consequence of the Red Sea diversions. Today, approximately 8% of global capacity (or 2.3m TEU) is now absorbed due to port congestion. This is expected to rise further in the coming weeks.

Ship bunching and congestion has spread to ports in Asia including Singapore, Shanghai, Qingdao and Shenzhen, with vessels waiting up to five days for a berthing slot in some ports.

Singapore, one of the world’s largest ports, has seen container volumes rise nearly 10% so far this year, and berthing delays are now extending beyond five days, with over 350,000 TEU currently waiting to berth. Singapore’s Maritime and Port Authority (MPA) said the congestion is the culmination of months of disruption triggered by the vessel diversions avoiding the Red Sea leading to bunching of vessels arriving into the port.

In the first week of the June, only six out of eleven Asia-Europe sailings departed on schedule, due to delays on the Eastbound voyage caused by the port congestion at the key hub ports of Singapore and Tanjung Pelepas.

Looking ahead
With ocean freight demand expected to continue into the summer, the danger is that average vessel waiting times will continue to lengthen, due to increased cargo flows and lowered terminal productivity, which in turn impedes facility operations. And when terminal capacity is limited, operators restrict the amount of cargo accepted, to avoid severe congestion, which simply serves to exacerbate the situation.

As primary hubs fill, transshipment networks require more ships to feed into peripheral ports, which means carriers may remove ships from other trades, which could create a new capacity squeeze and add further fuel to the fire pushing spot rates even higher.

Port congestion creates a de-facto reduction of available vessel capacity, which leads to an increase in blank sailings, because there is a schedule gap when vessels are unavailable, which again squeezes capacity.

We continue to monitor the evolving situation, while working closely with our local network and carrier partners to mitigate any impact on our customers.

We will keep you updated and provide alternative solutions where appropriate or necessary.

If you have any questions, concerns, or would like any further information regarding the situation outlined here, please EMAIL our Chief Commercial Officer, Andy Smith.

US ports to offer storage while others struggle

Sea freight rates from Asia continue to spike and remain on an upward trajectory

Between the start of April and last week, average spot rates from the Far East into North Europe increased by 31%, the US West Coast 30%, Mediterranean 25% and US East Coast 22%, with spot rates to Europe currently $6,000-$7,500 and analysts suggesting they may hit $10,000.

Market demand reached record levels in Q1 2024, up by 9.2% compared to Q1 2023, and coming at a time when the Red Sea situation was already putting pressure on shipping capacity, rate increases were inevitable. But it is the speed at which market turmoil has developed, that is creating nervousness in the market, with spot rates to Europe rising 6% in the last week.

Schedule reliability is still far from pre-pandemic levels, with Q1 on-time performance mooted to be just 27% which, combined with pockets of congestion, port omissions, delays and missed departures is having a massive impact on equipment availability at export hubs.

COVID-19 supply chain disruption is fresh in the memory of shippers and fearing a squeeze on capacity during the peak season many are importing more goods now. The traditional peak period, like the weather, is changing its seasons.

Much of these increased volumes are moving on the spot market, which is putting upwards pressure on rates, particularly as rising port congestion and equipment shortages are further diminishing available capacity. 

In addition, with the delays and the  impact on shipping schedules, caused through both carrier voluntary or involuntary port blankings, contract capacity is being reduced or completely removed, against agreements made earlier in the year, or at the backend of 2023. Sound familiar?

Long term rates on major trades have remained relatively flat in Q2, but with reduced space availability they are not covering the forecast allocations forcing shippers to find alternatives for the shortfall in demand for box movements. 

Short term spot and FAK rates are the only real mechanism as an alternative solution and this is currently absorbing all available container slots in the westbound Asia/ Europe trades.

Meanwhile, carriers will continue to make money from the spot market’s additional volumes ahead of the traditional peak season and that is what we have seen in the rate increases in May that look to continue, and possibly accelerate, as we enter June. 

The shipping lines are not the cause of the current situation, but there are advantages to a commodity driven model, where demand exceeds supply from their perspective.

However, the large BCO shippers are too aware that the bigger the gap gets between the spot and contract markets, the greater the risk that more of their cargo may get rolled, in favour of higher-yielding containers. This creates further demand and a willingness to pay higher rates, to ensure that product is shipped and deadlines can be met.

Even if there is capacity in the market, the fear factor can push up rates and shippers could be facing months of further elevated rates and increased delays, if higher demand continues to overtake available capacity.

However, the duration and scale of these price spikes could be less severe than those seen during the pandemic because volumes are increasing and not surging, which should mean that ports will (in time) be able to handle the higher volumes and strategies developed during the pandemic, like off-port container yards, are already in place. 

It is unlikely that this can be sustainable long term for any party or for the length of time seen during the Covid Pandemic days of lockdowns and increased consumer spending. There are other factors at play, in creating a similar environment to 2020/21 market conditions.

As we advised many weeks ago, the next large scale disruption which is beginning to really have a major effect is the lack of equipment where it is required in the manufacturing regions of Asia, due to shortages of available empty containers that are either ‘stuck’ on longer transiting vessels, or laying idle at destination (such as the Med) awaiting evacuation back to Asia. 

The impact in China is becoming very acute with a lack of available empty boxes creating bottle necks throughout the main gateways and congestion and queueing times increasing daily for vessels.

In addition, if the demand increase has been driven by an early start to the peak season, then we may expect demand-side pressure to begin easing off in a few months, although volumes and rates are likely to remain elevated for a while longer, due to the turbulence that is a consequence of the market conditions that are currently at play throughout the globe.

We will continue to update on the evolving situation, which is gathering pace due to many factors and dynamics. We do not foresee any short term rectification of the current market conditions which will undoubtedly continue to pay havoc with supply chains. 

We will always offer the best options available, being creative with the solutions that we offer – based on customer requirements – ensuring we always deliver against deadlines.

With carriers in the ‘driving seat’, they are cherry-picking which contracts to honour, rolling lower-yield containers and blanking vessels, to try and recover schedules.

With the market this challenging, there is no ’silver bullet’ and many shippers that try to play the spot market are coming unstuck.

Metro are leveraging our long-standing carrier relationships and sensible annual contracts, to guarantee our customers space and set rates.

To learn how we can enhance your ocean freight solutions, please EMAIL our Chief Commercial Officer, Andy Smith. 

Singapore boats at anchor 1440x1080 1

Global port congestion threat to capacity

The Red Sea crisis and the much longer sailing distances triggered by the diversion around Africa’s Cape of Good Hope (COGH) soaked up existing market overcapacity, which was just enough to cope with the extended COGH transit times, provided there were no additional disruptions to maritime supply chains.

The demand spike that began in Q1 caught everyone by surprise, but while speeding up vessels may have released additional capacity, increasing port congestion has eradicated any benefit from that capacity and is exacerbating an already serious situation.

Port congestion in Asia and the Western Mediterranean has been gradually worsening for several months, but it is only now becoming plain that with zero excess capacity in the market to deal with new problems, port congestion is a critical issue.

Shanghai, Ningbo, Qingdao and Singapore are particular chokepoints, with the latter’s berthing delays reaching seven days, forcing some carriers to omit planned calls, which will exacerbate the problem at downstream ports, that will have to handle additional volumes.

The delays have also resulted in vessel bunching, which contributes further to berthing delays and operations at downstream ports.

A current example of the accumulative impact of port congestion is ONE’s vessel, the MOL Presence, operating its Japan-Straits Malaysia loop. The vessel was six days late when it called at Hong Kong on the 12th May, which increased to seven days when it reached Port Klang in Malaysia, while congestion at Singapore means it would be 10 days late calling there on the 23rd May.

In terms of sailings on the westbound trade, 128 container vessels arrived in North Europe during April against an advertised 169. That’s a 25% reduction against expectations.

Western Mediterranean ports have been handling massively increased volumes as carriers from Asia drop boxes destined for the eastern Mediterranean and while they managed Q1 throughput, they are operating close to operational capacity, which means that any continuation or increase in volumes could lead to potentially serious congestion.

Port congestion and the consequential delayed vessel schedules is also creating issues with empty container availability, as boxes become delayed in transit, resulting in lower stock availability in the regions and at ports where they are needed. This impact is escalating daily on some trades and we will continue to update as this next challenge evolves at a fast rate.

The disruptions and higher sea freight prices from Asia could push even more volumes to sea/air solutions, that offer massively faster transit times than ocean, while being far less expensive than air freight.

It is important to note that while we are seeing dramatic increases on trades out of the Far East, the export spot market remains flat and there is also little movement on the Transatlantic trade.

We work closely with our network and carrier partners to monitor port congestion and equipment availability across Asia and Europe, with contingency plans to ensure product is delivered to market, without delay, until congestion finally subsides.

To learn how we can help you avoid disruption and port congestion, or to request our regular ocean market report, please EMAIL our sea freight director, Andy Smith, who can advise on the best solutions for your ocean supply chain.